How does Penelope react when Odysseus proves he . What news does Athena share with Telemachus? The beggar/Odysseus has impressive answers, citing a purple woolen cape and a gold clasp with a hound clenching a fawn. Accordingly, Irus the beggar tries to drive Odysseus the beggar away from the palace. Homer uses minor characters of low rank to great effect in Books 17 and 18. 3. How is Argus a symbol of Odysseus himself? At the end of the poem, he's as much of a wily, fearless hero as he ever was. Zeus makes it thunder. 4. Answer: Melanthios betrayed Oddysseus. Odysseus has been disguised as an old beggar by Athena so that he will be able to surprise the suitors in the palace. 1)Telemachus calls Eumaues a dear friend because the two of them were close and Eumaeus was very loyal to Telemachus' father, Odysseus. Unlike the other suitors, he is never portrayed sympathetically, and he is the first to die when Odysseus returns. Odysseus answers with a fictitious autobiography that includes a friendship with her husband. Answer (1 of 3): A massive amount of local nobles were camped out in his home and were vying for his wife's hand in marriage and the power and income that came with it. Zeus makes it thunder. He tells her that, I've seen him around. Read Eumaeus' statement about servants in lines 1199-1203. Why do you think Penelope has such difficulty recognizing Odysseus? As the epic reaches its climax, two signs are sent from Olympus to indicate the god's approval of Odysseus. Of course, the beggar would not claim her for his bride; Odysseus would not have to. - 16730551 sydneip8192 sydneip8192 06/04/2020 English Middle School answered In at least 150 words, describe who Melanthius is. This character is the leader of the suitors, who hits Odysseus with a chair and is the first to die. Describe Odysseus and Penelope's bed and the process Odysseus used to build it? 11. 2.Odysseus tests the suitors by coming to their table and begging for food. December 7, 2011 @ 8:59 pm. In truth, Odysseus's character doesn't undergo much of a change throughout his epic voyage. What are they? Was Penelope aware that Odysseus was a beggar? In Odyssey 19, Odysseus, disguised as a beggar . How do Eumaeus' beliefs about servitude and slavery compare with those in your own culture? Even heroes sometimes allow their emotions to get the better of them. What are they? 3. Question 11. He throws a stool at the beggar/Odysseus but hits the wine steward instead. In order to thank him for this news Penelope calls the old nanny, Eurycleia, to come and wash the old man's feet. Because it was actually was Odysseus: Who recognized Odysseus, despite his rags, when he returns to his kingdom? 5. How does Odysseus react to her test? 2. He took the side of the Suitors, and during their fight against Odysseus and Tylemachos he tried to supply them with. How is Penelope interview with the beggar ironic? The beggar describes Odysseus's clothing, weapons, and men so perfectly that Penelope weeps. Each handle probably has a . Penelope tests him by asking specific questions about the clothing and comrades of Odysseus. 1. What important Greek value does Telemachus' and Eumaues' treatment of the unknown beggar reveal? Who are they, and why does he reveal himself to them? As Penelope listens to the description, she realizes "the beggar" is . The scene highlights once again the theme of xenia (guest . Describe the mood of book nineteen in one to two complete sentences. He tells Penelope that, essentially, Odysseus had a long ordeal but is alive and freely traveling the seas, and predicts that Odysseus will be back within the month.Penelope offers the beggar a bed to sleep in, but he is used to the floor, he says, and declines. & Because, they were the only two man who were praying & wanting Odysseus to return back home to Ithaca. 3.The dog, Argos, notices Odysseus right away. Analysis: Books 17-18. Swineherd (Emamus) & Cowherd (Philoeteus). 6. As the epic reaches its climax, two signs are sent from Olympus to indicate the god's approval of Odysseus. How does he describe Odysseus, and why do you think he adds these details? The idea that Odysseus. Eumaeus, Athena tells him to go to see him. What story does the beggar tell Penelope about Odysseus? Scholars have long pondered the details of the contest itself, the most debatable point being what shooting an arrow through a dozen axes actually means. This shows restraint, because Odysseus loves Argos but chooses not to approach the dog so he does not reveal his true identity to others. He mentions Odysseus' herald, Eurybates. While Homer uses epic simile for a variety of purposes, epic similes can often be read with a view to larger narrative considerations, and the simile in Odyssey 23.233-240 seems especially suited to such analysis. The theme of loyalty appears again when Odysseus rebukes Melantho, primarily because the maidservant is ignoring her queen's needs. Odysseus thought it was prophecy. Describe how he treats the beggar/Odysseus. Eurymachus - A manipulative, deceitful suitor. Q. Swineherd (Emamus) & Cowherd (Philoeteus). What does the treatment of the dog tell you about the suitors in Odysseus' kingdom? 2)First, she turned Odysseus onto an old beggar, then a nicely dressed young man, but later changed him into an old man again. When Odysseus returns Penelope doesn't recognize him and cannot be sure that Odysseus is really who he says he is. And he has been running into trouble but is a very smart man. Penelope tested Odysseus three times in the "Odyssey.". Cite. How does Penelope test Odysseus? Read the description of Argus in lines 1194-1196. How does Homer describe Penelope in the italics on page 942? When a quarrel breaks out between Irus and Odysseus, the suitors are amused and want to see the two men fight. Argos is the dog of Odysseus who has been mistreated after he left. 4. Odysseus will dress up as a begger. 2. He describes Odysseus in such an accurate way, and with so many details that she bursts into tears. She thought this was a sign of him coming back, but she didn't believe it. . When Telemachus returns to Ithaca, who does he visit first? How does Penelope test the truth of Odysseus the beggar's story regarding Odysseus? What does Odysseus the beggar tell Penelope about Odysseus how much of it is true? How does Penelope test Odysseus? She tests Odysseus by ordering her servant Eurycleia to move their marriage bed. & Because, they were the only two man who were praying & wanting Odysseus to return back home to Ithaca. Odysseus, disguised as a beggar and accompanied by Eumaeus, encounters Melanthius on his way into town, by the fountain . What does Antinous do in the Odyssey? 30 seconds. The latter is known for his smooth talk, but he loses control when Odysseus stands up to him. Intelligence is more highly prized than physical strength. The simile in question likens Penelope's recognition of Odysseus to the experience of shipwrecked men who reach land by swimming. In her second test, Penelope retrieved Odysseus' bow, stating she will marry the man who strings it and makes a perfect shot. 5. Give at least one peice of evidence to support your answer. December 5, 2011 @ 8:56 pm. He then predicts that she will be seeing her husband in less than a month. She is also spending her nights with Eurymachus. Odysseus ignores Argos but respects that he has been loyal. Odysseus will signal Telemachus to go an get all the weapons and armour. In the Greek mythology, with the name Melanthios or Melantheus, is known as a shepherd in Ithaca, mentioned in Odyssey, as the son of Dolios. The mood in book nineteen is sad and gloomy. Describe how he treats the beggar/Odysseus. In Book 19, Odysseus dressed as a beggar meets Penelope. Likewise, after Odysseus comes to the palace of Nausicaa's parents, Homer describes another bath that Odysseus is given ( Odyssey 8.416-468). To be sure that he has met Odysseus, she asks the beggar to describe her husband. Fagles and Knox offer this solution (p. 515): Each ax has its handle attached. a) She asked the beggar at which games Odysseus excelled b) She asks him to describe Odysseus' clothing, his person, and his companions c) She asked what Odysseus' ship looked like d) She asks him the month and year he visited with Odysseus Expert-verified answer arjunrv Odysseus was disguised as . If he is in disguise, they will not know that he has returned and will not be . Antinous leads the campaign to have Telemachus killed. 1.Theoclymenus told Penelope "Odysseus is already in his own dear land, Odysseus either moves about or stays in one place and plotting his vengeance on the suitors. For her final test, she requested the movement of . 4. Odysseus goes on to describe in great detail the clothes that Odysseus was wearing, as well as Odysseus' comrade Eurybates. Odysseus had been away for 20 years, and his allies from the Trojan war had not seen him for ten years. When Odysseus finds Argos, he is lying in piles of animal dung outside the castle. If anything were to happen to Odysseus, Telemachus had to stay strong. Athena told Telemachus to get rid of Penelope's suitors and go searching for news of his father. With Odysseus disguised as a beggar, she asked him about Odysseus' travels, clothing and personality. In Book 18 of Homer 's Odyssey, the title character, disguised as a beggar, battles against another beggar whose name is Irus. Why? Like many Homeric characters, neither the swineherd Melanthius nor the maidservant Melantho is very developed. 3)Telemachus thinks Odysseus is a demon because he . After Argos recognizes his old master, he dies . The hawk was Odysseus. Penelope has not seen her husband for many years. They are little more than male and female versions of the same malevolent person: each ostensibly works for Odysseus but has become a . Revenge is sometimes justified, even if it involved killing. 12. If the suitors confronted him, then tell them that he was told to take them because he is trying to protect from further damage and if that still didn't .
Why Is Courtney Webb Leaving Qvc, What Happened To Yashoda After Krishna Left, Why Was Buttercup Called The Queen Of Garbage?, How Does A Vpn Protect You From Your Isp, What Does The Last Name Cruz Mean, How To Cook With A Convection Steam Oven,
how does the beggar describe odysseus